- This topic has 5 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 6 years, 1 month ago by
athelstane.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Home › Forums › Game Developers Discussions › Magic and Tech: Pre Development Questions
Tagged: rules discussion, WIP
I have been told not to let the fans build the game and to me, it makes plenty of sense. No rulebook can have everything a player wants for each of our tastes are different and it the rules did have everything we wanted, it would be a jumbled, confusing mess of a rule system.
But I think these questions will benefit me as the answers will be at the minimum, entertaining and interesting to the most, very informative.
Long story short, I am aiming to create my own line of minis to coincide with my rules but before I go that far, I want to ask you some questions. The first being about terrain. How many pieces do you generally use and how large? If it helps, I aim for a 28mm range for my line. Failing that, them I can create a general purpose ruleset that anyone can use.
That requires some questions back, how large is the gaming area likely to be, is the game rank and file or skirmish and can you interact with buildings in the rules?
As a writer of skirmish games I often say that you cannot have enough terrain, and that no piece of terrain should be more than a fast move from any other.
However, as noyjatat says, we need to know what size game you are aiming to create; skirmish, large skirmsh/small unit action, company level, regimental level etc.? Are we talking formed up units or individual figures?
I am aiming at platoon sized games. No fewer than a team of 4 and no more than 30-50 and 1-5 vehicles/ walkers/ etc. I am not planning on packing a table full of troops and have them move around like the terrain is an after thought. Terrain is gonna be key in survival and offer tactical and strategical assets to utilize. But I also aim for some form of simplicity.
The idea I am working with is that each player draws for every square foot, 3 terrain cards that; after talking to their opponent what type of battlefield they would like, shuffle up the terrain cards and without looking at them, place them anywhere on the table.
The cards can be from a single tree to a group of trees, a building, a rock that is sticking out of the ground for some reason, etc.
Here is an extract from one of my games to give you some ideas:
The following options are suggested for setting up terrain:
1. Cooperation. The players cooperate in producing a pleasing and suitable terrain setup, perhaps referring to actual landscapes.
2. Place Then Choose. One player lays out the playing area and identifies where troops can deploy onto it. The other player(s) then choose their deployment location(s); if there are more than 2 players, roll for the order of choice but the player who laid out the terrain will always go last.
3. Defender’s Choice. If the scenario involves an attack against a defended position, then the defender may choose the terrain.
4. Alternating Choice. Each player is allowed to pick an agreed number of terrain pieces which are then placed one at a time; roll to determine the order in which the players place each piece.
I generally prefer option 1, and often play using option 2. Note that all these ideas require no cards or other complicating factors.
You do need to determine what each type of terrain does in the game. Does it block line of sight? Does it provide troops and/or vehicles with cover and if so, how much?
This stretched my game design mind as well. I came up with a fifth option, and given I am striving to cut the rules down to one sheet of A4, it reduced the length of the rules. The ‘fifth option’: have a set of scenarios with terrain already mapped out.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Supported by (Turn Off)
5
Warhammer 40,000 Armageddon Minis Revealed! What Do You Think?
1
Duncan Rhodes Teases Death Reaper Games Project
1
Perry Miniatures 8mm Travelbattle Heads To The Lace Wars
1
Demonic Usurpers & More Come To Mantic Games’ Kings Of War
1
John Blanche’s En Garde 54mm Figures Now On Kickstarter
3
Grab Stunning Sci-Fantasy Warpland RPG Figures With Taiga’s Kickstarter
14
Games Workshop Kick Off Grot Week For Warhammer 40,000 [Updated]
4
Two Twisted New Characters Coming To TTCombat’s Carnevale Soon
2
Spectre Miniatures Add New North Korean Sets To Their Range
2
Unleash Avatars Of War’s Plastic Stone Trolls On Fantasy Battlefields
5
Grab Armies Of The Commonwealth Rules & Gurkhas Soon For Bolt Action!
11
Modiphius Drop A Teaser For New XCOM: The Miniatures Game!
2
Satyr Celebrate Oldhammer With Dwarves, Giants & Chaos Knights
4
Slave 2 Gaming Release A 28mm Alien Invasion On The Tabletop
0
Fracture; The Next Chapter Coming To Mantic Games’ Kings Of War
0
Unleash Winter’s Bite & Brutish Wild Warriors On Conquest
0
Algeroth Killers & Mishima Samurai On The Way For Warzone Eternal
1
Grab The Final Edition Of Sci-Fi Skirmish Game, Planet 28
9
Humiliate Your Foes With New WW2 Bad Squiddo Miniatures
3
New Dragon Lancers For Celtos Ride Forth From Brigade Models
0
The Alliance Heave Into View With New Dystopian Wars Starter Set
2
Crooked Dice Let Four New Djinn Miniatures Out Of The Bottle
4
New Star Wars: Legion Mandalorians Now Up For Pre-Order
2
Fight The Iron Valley Campaign In Midgard Heroic Battles
2
10mm Union Assault Regiment Brings Air Support To Armoured Clash
7
Warlord Switching To Plastic Weapon Teams For Bolt Action
1
Download And Print Warlord’s Konflikt ’47 Sturmriese For FREE
1
Knuckleduster’s Hollywood Cavalry Ride Into Gunfighter’s Ball
4
Footsore Miniatures & Games’ Return To Cry Havoc Now On Kickstarter
1
Get Your Hands On The German A7V Heavy Tank For WWI Game, 1918
Painting in Tabletop Gaming
Technical Support
Fantasy Tabletop Game Discussions
News, Rumours & General Discussion
News, Rumours & General Discussion
News, Rumours & General Discussion
Painting in Tabletop Gaming
Painting in Tabletop Gaming
Painting in Tabletop Gaming
News, Rumours & General Discussion
News, Rumours & General Discussion
News, Rumours & General Discussion
Science Fiction Tabletop Game Discussions
Painting in Tabletop Gaming
News, Rumours & General Discussion
News, Rumours & General Discussion
Technical Support
Technical Support
Science Fiction Tabletop Game Discussions
News, Rumours & General Discussion
Copyright © 2026 Beasts of War Ltd.
All trademarks and images are copyright of their respective owners.