Cult Of Games XLBS: What Is The Future Of Historical Wargaming?
October 11, 2026 by crew
For some website features, you will need a FREE account and for some others, you will need to join the Cult of Games.
Or if you have already joined the Cult of Games Log in now
What difference will having a FREE account make?
Setting up a Free account with OnTableTop unlocks a load of additional features and content (see below). You can then get involved with our Tabletop Gaming community, we are very helpful and keen to hear what you have to say. So Join Us Now!
Free Account Includes
- Creating your own project blogs.
- Rating and reviewing games using our innovative system.
- Commenting and ability to upvote.
- Posting in the forums.
- Unlocking of Achivments and collectin hobby xp
- Ability to add places like clubs and stores to our gaming database.
- Follow games, recommend games, use wishlist and mark what games you own.
- You will be able to add friends to your account.
What's the Cult of Games?
Once you have made a free account you can support the community by joing the Cult of Games. Joining the Cult allows you to use even more parts of the site and access to extra content. Check out some of the extra features below.
Cult of Games Membership Includes
- Reduced ads, for a better browsing experience (feature can be turned on or off in your profile).
- Access to The Cult of Games XLBS Sunday Show.
- Extra hobby videos about painting, terrain building etc.
- Exclusive interviews with the best game designers etc.
- Behind the scenes studio VLogs.
- Access to our live stream archives.
- Early access to our event tickets.
- Access to the CoG Greenroom.
- Access to the CoG Chamber of Commerce.
- Access the CoG Bazarr Trading Forum.
- Create and Edit Records for Games, Companies and Professionals.
Supported by (Turn Off)
Supported by (Turn Off)
Supported by (Turn Off)

Happy Sunday Backstagers, OTTers and shoulder wiggle inducing CoGs!
@avernos Furry ferocity with a heroic halfling is great to see finally. Stuff sitting around should always find a use.
@johnlyons Your infatuation with mecha mommies is pure heresy for both 40k and the new Gundam game.
@brennon We always had hope for you not to be a degen from upcountry. What sad times we live in.
The divide of factual history from Hollywood is the exposure. The sense of possibly winning a battle is probably what draws a good number of players to play. Its a bit grim to walk solemnly into suicide solely for the ritual of reenactment. Granted, as I agree with the reenactment and acting crowd, somebody needs to play the losers of the battle. I just think that, like the Southpark Civil War battle, the sidestep you pointed out is a little bit more engaging and open for interaction with an audience that looks for agency.
@ horati0nosebl0wer
South Park is, and has always been South AMERICA.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER.
🤪
Historic wargaming. I get the impression that this conversation implies that Conan and Battletech , though great games are not historical……my heart is broken.
Seriously though. Admitedly not been dragged into true historical wargaming, too lazy to paint armies that large. But I love playing Flames of War and historical scenarios of Joan or Arc. I’ve often felt that these events really felt like historical wargaming because those present were interested in the subject and more history was shared and learnt inbetween rounds than actually played.
Once everyone present is expert, true historical gaming can only be taken so far as any rule system will have to cut corners on scale or reality so it will allways distil back to entertaining what if’s. The real question is what ingedients do you throw into your what if. Does a particular general magicaly get diarrhea just before the big battle and and roll his dice really badly or do your armies get handed alien tech to develop stompy robots.
For me historical on the table top is always contextual.
It may or may not happen actually means it’ll happen but at the same rate as Lloyd building Rome does…..
I’ve been looking for a good set of modern combat rules to play games in 20 and 28mm.
One of my concerns regarding historical is that it’s aging out, and I’m not talking about the player base but the manufacturers. Many historical miniature companies are small cottage industries run by gamers who coming close to retirement. Now some ranges out there will be picked up but some are going to go simply because there aren’t enough people/companies to pick up all of them.
Bolt Action is essentially Hollywood WW2 on the tabletop.
I couldn’t care about the miniatures, at the end of the day a US ranger is the same regardless of the company that manufactured it. But it’s the games I’m more concerned with, are people incapable of actually playing a realistic game anymore, do we really have to image our 25 mins are “part of a larger battle”?
Thats better clarification to your subject this weekend. The question might be “Is there a drive of historical interest for simulation with dice rolling on top or a game where you roll dice with historical window dressing?”.
It boils down to “edutainment”. See the big screen entertainment production, fall into “I’d like to know more” and then work on the curiosity from interest.
That’s painfully true. When Adler Miniatures announced their retirement, I almost had a panic attack. I had armies to complete and plan/projects for new armies and periods not started. Thankfully the miniature range was purchased by Heroics and Ros (but you never hear any news from them or see them covered by wargaming magazines or websites. But what happens when Heroics and Ros decide to retire? Logically this can’t continue forever, or we would see one company (with EXTREMELY deep pockets) own all the historical miniatures in ALL scales. Nor could we expect to see the Wargaming Historical Miniatures ranges “nationalised” by a government (although that would be nice to see) 😀
I always find wargaming in a historical setting much more enjoyable than wargaming a historixal battle. Historical settings allow me to be a general. I know what my army does and get to decide how to use it. Simlarly, most miniature wargames are tactical, not strategic games. Campaigns can link tactical engagements, but we all know they often ‘fail’ to go the distance,
That said, Tactical/Historical battles often tie my hands and lock me into a situation where I’m expected to replay history. My issue with that is that I often know what happened and would make the same errors or be able to re-enact the ‘surprise’ manouver unless my opponent plays along. A great example is Canne. If I’m the Romans and don’t do what Hannibal planned, what happens? The battle is almost always a massacre of the Hannibal’s army (the Romans has numbers, equipment, training etc, which is why the Carthaginian victory is so amazing). The same for the Battle of Kursk if I’m the Germans. If I’m playing a strategic game starting at the battle of Kursk, I don’t fight Kursk, because unlike Hitler, I’m not an idiot. If I was forced to fight it, my goals would probably be to do as much damage to the soviets for the lightest losses rather than attacking a well defended, numerically superior opponent.
Historical settings – Yes! Historical battles – No!
Personally I much prefer the refight of a battle. Sure it might have unmatched forces, and we might know exactly how the battle was fought. But having played many, many games over the year (although admittedly the majority of these were when I was in my 20s with a lot more time to spare). having the army list set by the OOB and the deployment set by how the troops were set up on the line by the Generals in charge, I know that after the first few turns and after a few dice have been thrown thing usually change drastically from what happened on the day (for example Waterloo is usually won by the French 9 out of 10 times, even with rules added to restrict French movement because the gamers know EXACTLY when the Prussians turn up)). I like the refight because it tends to move the game out of the gamers comfort zone (matched points, set objectives). I’ve also enjoyed the “fictional” historical game, but only if the rules system adds mechanics to throw a spanner in the works. I remember playing a WW2 game in 6mm (I still can’t remember to this day the name, because I would buy multiple copies to give to my wargaming mates) that had a system where you paid for armour using points as normal, but depending on their historical record or the state of each armies logistics to rolled a dice to see if they actually turned up for the battle. So buying Panthers or Tigers had a risk applied to them of breaking down somewhere off table, whereas more mechanically reliable like Pzer 4s or Stugs would almost always turned up. Off course if you got lucky on the dice rolls and actually got those units to appear on table they would dominate things. Infantry ALWAYS turned up (so they were a no risk purchase). So even if the army lists were matched points, after the dice rolls for armour assets turning up then the games usually had uneven forces on turn 1.
TOLLEN SONNTAG ALLEN!
00:00 Kangs of Waaaaagh. Where video?!
01:30 zoidpinhead making us all look very very lazy and bad XD
02:00 Oh noooooooooooooes!
04:30 censorship on the XLBS? Boooooh
08:30 All the bells and whistles
11:11 none will do it!
12:35 @amachan and I also got involved and I think @grayprimer also?
13:21 DA FUQ?! XD
16:13 almost missed the cue there
27:30 Ballbusters!
28:45 some very mental entries
29:00 Only I did the banana! XD
30:00 Doctor Jones! Little Indie!
47:00 BEN! You naughty naughty boy! I almost spilled my coffee!
1:09:00 I just don’t get the appeal of historical gaming. Maybe it’s just because “it’s all fixed and done”. And too many people shouting that you used the wrong green on the uniform, you have one button to many etc pp. If it’s made up you can’t tell me it’s wrong.
1:19:00 Racer go wuuuuuuuuuuuuush
What was this weeks question again?
Interesting discussion on historicals – well done to John for a well prepared conversation!
I’ll be interested in following the next chapter. I have yet to play an actual historical game. There are settings I am drawn to, but in the same way as history is ‘fixed’ because it actually happened, the outcome also actually happened. So I can’t see a reason for me (personal view) to reenact it. Gaming in the historical setting, but in a fictitious battle, seems much more appealing. The outcome is open, and me and my opponent are the fictitious generals seeing how we would approach a battle with the resources and constraints of that period. That feels more like a ‘game’ to me. I’ll be tuned in next week!
Personally initially I was drawn to an era largely by a TV show or film I saw as a kid, or by the next shiny, but now I’m more attracted by the rules I can play, so Lion Rampant, and pretty much the Rampant family of games.
Personal national history such as WOTR, ECW, etc has a big influence on what I’m drawn to, That being said ACW was piqued by Epic Battles, as has been AWI.
I also think that scale and game type are a big factor in the historical representation now, also influenced by what we see on film and TV the Epic sized films are gone, been 20+ years since films like Kingdom of Haven, Troy, Alexander, Gladiator, Saving Private Ryan, Fury. There’s a reason that Zulu a film older than I am has stood the test of time, along with Waterloo, they literally don’t make them like that anymore. Its like the last real Epic battle in film I can think off is Battle of Scariff and thats not exactly historical, same with Avengers Assemble.
So Band of Brothers, platoon sized series with a few tanks, heck the Bolt Action starter was called Band of Brothers, The Last Kingdom with Warbands and we have Pillage, Ravenfeast, Midgard. the larger figures have got, the games get smaller, less figures and playable in 2×2 space.
I think also the gaming size folks have, Legion to fit on a 5×3 the kitchen table, the old 6×4 or bigger billiards tables are a different time.
So unless smaller scale = bigger games, I think we should expect to continue to see the Heroic 28mm or larger played on a coffee table type rules.
I don’t mind that as there options in the gaps, epic gaming is possible with 4×4 rules from League of Augsburg, Peter Pig and Grid based wargaming, Ton the Strongest, for King and Parliament, even hex and counter can still be a thing with miniatures.
Hi XLBSers an COGz ⚙️
Don’t forget all the Woke PC re-righting they are doing to history now too appease the idiot’s around now John 🤔🙆
Over the years there has been a move from the “simulation” rules I started with in the 70’s and 80’s. For example in the era of WRG 5th to 7th you were concerned with what armour, weapon and training the unit had. Another example were the Bruce Quarrie Napoleonic rules where again training, “class” and national characteristics all played a part in the game as well as the need for a knowledge of maths and geometry if you wanted to win the game 😉.
Over the years there has been a vast simplification of the rules but some still provide a challenge to play and give a reasonable “simulation” while others are “Hollywood” and can be played in a couple of hours for fun (remove brain and enjoy).
I think a lot of the changes have been an attempt to add “friction” into the game and remove the “all seeing eye” of the general which I know from reaction of some players is not popular.
So if you look at WW2 for example the group I play with use the following rules:
All with varying levels of “realism” and paly best when you use the appropriate tactics.
The best example however is Napoleonic Naval:
So are a people incapable of playing a realistic game – no but it has to be something they are really interested in and willing to put the time in not only learning the rules but also learning the tactics of the particular era or war.
But a lot of people really use the “game” as a way to socialise so the more simple games let them get “toys” on the table and have fun.
One other point that is always raised is the “min max” or “super armies” that people say came for Games Workshop influence in competition games. This has always been present in “historical” competition games from the 70’s and 80’s when each edition of the WRG rules through up the “super army” (some would say whatever the author was playing at the time) and a great number of hours were spent studying army list to drag the best possible value out of your points allowance.
Happy Monday…..yes i am watching on a Monday again.
I shall allow it
Anyone know of a UK supplier for Atomic Tank? I can’t find one
“The future of historical wargames”, that’s a difficult one…..
The thing that has to change is basically the player base AND the miniature manufacturers who also build a closed eco system (ie they also publish their own rules/accessories/cards/proprietary dice etc).
At the moment I think most people here if they do play historical games probably play a skirmish based system. Personally I’m not that big of a fan because of the limitations of the sub-genre. Basically you’ve got a mini at is either ranged or melee based, the ratio of each is probably based on the historical period (ie Ancients/Dark Ages probably the majority are going to be melee based. WW2 probably ALL the minis are ranged based). But no matter what the period the weapons behave the same. Slings and Pistols will act the same (low range/damage), Crossbows and Bolt Action Rifles similar (higher range and damage). Or to put it more simply you could write a skirmish set of rules and it could cover ALL historical periods, fantasy and sci-fi. The mechanics remain the same only the weapon list will change for each period.
You have to move the level of the game “up” to begin to see the differences between the historical periods. Orders are sent by horseback/runner until WW2 where you see radios appear (which changes things drastically). Moderns we would begin to see rules for drones appear etc. To move that game “upwards” you need to bring the tactical level upwards are well (so perhaps battalion rank and flank for games prior to WW2, and company level for WW2 onwards. This would also probably mean that the scale of the minis needs to be smaller to allow games to fit on your average 6X4 table. So 15mm and below (one of the reasons why we’ve seen so many skirmish level rules and games systems is to use the cheap 28mm plastics that have dominated the market for the past 20 years. If you look at how the games have developed over the past 20 years the demise of rank and flank gaming and the rise of skirmish gaming almost perfectly matches the rise in both availability and popularity of 28mm multipart plastics.
Next up, keeping in the gamers mindset. One of the issues with historical gaming is that the miniatures have all been done 20 years ago. Fantasy and Sci-fi keep introducing new IP/Universes and new miniatures for the games, so they constantly are in the Wargaming News. Historicals rarely see completely new periods hit the market, so we just don’t hear about them as often. We would need to “rediscover” these historical mini companies and have our memories retriggered or for newer gamers perhaps discover these companies for the first time. It’s one of the reasons why I enjoy the “Indie of the Week” segments here on BoW, although apparently it doesn’t do too well on the viewing statistics compared to other segments of news from BoW (so kudos to BoW for keeping that flame alive).
So for historicals to move beyond endless releases of skirmish level rulesets/minis, we would probably need to see a resurgence of the older scales of minis (15mm/6mm etc). Perhaps we’ve seen Warlord see the stagnation of things (and why gaming seems to “samey” over the past 20 years), with them trying to bring back the rank and flank game and moving the mini scale back down with their Epic ranges (although personally I feel they charge WAY too much for the sprues, but then I feel Warlord charge a bit too much no matter what scale of mini you are buying).